Joint Statement on the Mandate on LAWS

Thank you, Acting Chair-Designate!

I am speaking on behalf of the delegations of Utrecht University, from the Netherlands, and the Asia-Pacific Institute for Law and Security, from Australia. 

At the outset, I would like to thank the High Contracting Parties that have voiced their support for the role of observers. I would also like to express our gratitude to Ambassador Thöni, Ambassador Schialer, and to yourself, sir, for facilitating consultations in a manner that permits us to participate.

Chair,

Under the excellent leadership of Ambassador in den Bosch and his team, the GGE on LAWS has adopted a rich set of elements of an instrument. Those elements are incomplete but—along with the earlier work of the GGE—provide a good starting point for elaborating a binding instrument on LAWS. We welcome and support your proposal, Chair, to negotiate a Protocol on this basis over a two-year period.

Some delegations have expressed concerns that a new Protocol might create fragmentation in the legal framework. In our view, the elements of an instrument that the GGE has adopted are closely aligned with established law. The Convention itself also guards against the risk of inconsistency. Article 2 provides that nothing in the Convention or its annexed Protocols shall be interpreted as detracting from other obligations imposed by IHL. 

Where a new Protocol goes beyond existing law, it develops IHL the way IHL has been regularly developed: by treaty, among consenting States, and without detracting from obligations that already exist. The greater risk to IHL lies elsewhere: in recasting and potentially diluting existing legal requirements in a non-binding instrument.

Should some High Contracting Parties consider that certain elements cannot be given legally binding force, the mandate could provide for the elaboration of both a Protocol and non-legally binding measures. This would follow an approach already taken in the Open-ended Working Group on the Prevention of an Arms Race in Outer Space.

Chair, 

Many delegations have described the CCW as the appropriate forum for this work. That argument remains persuasive only if the CCW can deliver. Procedural challenges have plagued the Convention for years, as also demonstrated by the current discussions occurring in the form of informal consultations. If the Conference could not agree on a negotiating mandate after a decade of discussion, many would legitimately ask whether the Convention remains relevant to the realities of modern armed conflicts. 

The CCW was designed to evolve, by codifying and progressively developing international law as new weapons raise new concerns. A mandate with a clear path toward a new Protocol would show that the Convention can still do that.

I thank you, Chair!